Structural Comparisons • Wissenszentrum

Leichtbaustahl vs. Schwerer Stahlbau: Der technische Vergleich

Wann eignet sich Kaltprofilstahl (LGSF) und wann warmgewalzter Profilstahl für Ihr Bauvorhaben?

Autor: İdris YAĞMAHAN (Architekt) Fachlich geprüft von: Celalettin YAĞMAHAN (Leitender Bauingenieur) Lesezeit: 9 Min. Lesezeit Aktualisiert: 2026-02-28
Eurocode 3 & 8 Statik & Prüffähigkeit
EN 1090-2 Güteüberwachte Fertigung
40ft HC Containerverpackung (Flat-Pack)
100% Schraubmontage (Kein Schweißen)

⚡ Kompaktüberblick / Zusammenfassung

Choosing between Light Gauge Steel (LGSF / CFS per EN 1993-1-3) and Heavy Hot-Rolled Structural Steel (S355JR per EN 1993-1-1) depends fundamentally on building geometry, clear span requirements, and payload types. Light gauge steel utilizes thin cold-formed galvanized profiles (0.8mm to 2.5mm, S350GD) to create dense, lightweight load-bearing wall panels and roof trusses—ideal for residential villas, multi-family housing, modular units, and commercial offices up to 4 storeys (spans up to 12m). Heavy structural steel utilizes hot-rolled I-beams (IPE, HEA, HEB) and welded plate girders (6mm to 30mm+) to achieve expansive unobstructed clear spans (18m to 60m+), high eave heights (6m to 20m), and heavy overhead crane support for industrial warehouses and factories.

Wichtigste Erkenntnisse & Kostenvorteile

  • ✔ Clear Span Threshold: LGS is economical for spans up to 12m; Heavy Structural Steel is required for spans of 18m to 60m+
  • ✔ Weight Comparison: LGS superstructures weigh 20–35 kg/m²; Heavy Structural Steel portal frames weigh 30–65 kg/m²
  • ✔ Foundation Savings: LGS reduces concrete foundation volume and excavation costs by 25–35% due to ultra-low dead weight
  • ✔ Crane Integration: Only Heavy Hot-Rolled Steel can support 5t to 32t dynamic overhead traveling bridge cranes
  • ✔ Residential Dominance: LGS provides superior acoustic and thermal wall multi-layer cavity assemblies for modern housing
  • ✔ Hybrid Synergy: SerBuild frequently engineers Hybrid buildings (Heavy portal columns for clear spans + LGS interior infill walls)

1. Material Properties & Structural Behavior Comparison

Both systems utilize structural steel, but their manufacturing metallurgy and load transfer mechanics differ fundamentally:

  • Cold-Formed Light Gauge Steel (LGSF / CFS): Produced by roll-forming galvanized coil (EN 10346 S350GD+Z275) at ambient temperatures into C, U, and Z sections (0.8mm–2.5mm thick). Loads are distributed across a dense network of closely spaced wall studs (every 400mm–600mm) and engineered lattice trusses.
  • Hot-Rolled Heavy Structural Steel: Hot-rolled at ~1,100°C into solid thick-walled I-sections (IPE, HEA, HEB per EN 10025-2 S355JR) or welded from heavy structural plate. Loads are concentrated onto discrete, widely spaced portal columns and heavy rafters spaced at 6.0m to 8.0m bay intervals.
  • Seismic Ductility: LGS structures absorb seismic energy through screw connection deformation and strap bracing, exhibiting high damping ratios. Heavy steel frames absorb seismic energy through plastic hinge formation at rafter-column joints (Eurocode 8 MRF systems).

2. Technical Parameter Matrix: LGSF vs Heavy Structural Steel

The matrix below compares the engineering and financial metrics of both framing technologies (2026 benchmarks):

📊 Detaillierte Kosten- & Spezifikationstabelle (€ / m²)

Engineering Metric Light Gauge Steel (LGSF / CFS) Hot-Rolled Heavy Structural Steel Hybrid Steel Solution
Steel Grade & Standard S350GD+Z275 (EN 10346, Cold-formed) S355JR / S355J2 (EN 10025, Hot-rolled) S355JR Primary + S350GD Secondary
Steel Thickness Range 0.8 mm – 2.5 mm 6.0 mm – 40.0 mm+ Combined (0.9mm to 25mm)
Superstructure Framing Cost €95 – €180 / m² €65 – €130 / m² €85 – €150 / m²
Superstructure Dead Weight 20 – 35 kg / m² 30 – 65 kg / m² 28 – 48 kg / m²
Maximum Economical Clear Span 8 – 12 meters (Truss: 15m) 18 – 60+ meters (Clear portal) 24 – 36 meters
Storey Height Capability 1 to 4 Storeys (Load-bearing) 1 to 15+ Storeys (Moment frame) 1 to 6 Storeys
Crane Runway Capability Light Jib Crane (≤ 1.0t) only Heavy Bridge Cranes (5t – 32t+) Heavy Cranes in frame bay only
On-Site Assembly Method Self-drilling screws & rivet fasteners Grade 8.8 / 10.9 high-strength bolts Bolted frame + screwed infill

🔍 Vergleichende Ingenieurmatrix

Building Archetype Optimal Structural System Primary Engineering Rationale Estimated Cost Saving
Residential Villa / Modern House (150–350 m²) Light Gauge Steel (LGSF) Passivhaus thermal walls, fast dry construction, flexible floor plan 15% – 25% vs Concrete
Logistics & Storage Warehouse (1,000–10,000 m²) Heavy Structural Steel Wide unobstructed clear spans (24–36m), high eave clearance (7–12m) 20% – 30% vs Precast Concrete
Manufacturing Facility with 10t Crane Heavy Structural Steel Heavy column corbels, dynamic fatigue resistance per EN 1993-6 Mandatory (Only Heavy Steel qualifies)
Commercial Office with Storage Hall Hybrid Steel System Heavy steel clear-span hall + LGS multi-office mezzanine block 12% – 18% vs pure heavy frame
Modular Portable Buildings / Camp Housing Light Gauge Steel (LGSF) Compact flat-pack shipping, fast containerized assembly, light weight 25% – 35% vs container conversions

📋 Schrittweiser Projektablauf

01

1. Clear Span Assessment

Determine whether unobstructed spans over 15m are required for operations.

02

2. Building Use Classification

Classify into Residential/Modular (LGS advantage) vs Industrial/Logistics (Heavy steel advantage).

03

3. Crane & Heavy Equipment Audit

Check if bridge cranes, heavy storage racks, or dynamic machines are planned.

04

4. Foundation & Geotechnical Review

Calculate if poor soil bearing capacity favors lightweight LGS construction.

05

5. Consider Hybrid System

Evaluate if combining heavy perimeter portals with internal LGS wall cassettes offers maximum ROI.

06

6. Structural Sizing by SerBuild

Receive side-by-side engineering models and comparative budget proposals.

Benötigen Sie eine projektspezifische Statik & Preiskalkulation?

Senden Sie uns Maße, Spannweiten und Standortkoordinaten. Unsere Statikabteilung erstellt innerhalb von 24–48 Stunden eine detaillierte Kostenschätzung und eine Eurocode-Bewertung.

Projektangebot anfordern → WhatsApp Technische Beratung

Häufig gestellte Fragen (FAQ)

Detaillierte Antworten zu Eurocode-Statik, Fertigung, Export und Montage vor Ort.

LGS is not economical for large open industrial warehouses requiring 20m+ clear spans without interior columns. For warehouses, heavy hot-rolled steel portal frames are far more cost-effective and provide completely unobstructed floor space.

A Hybrid system is often the most economical: heavy hot-rolled steel beams and columns form the main wide-span structural grid, while lightweight LGS wall panels and floor joists form the interior acoustic and thermal partitions.

LGS profiles feature continuous hot-dip zinc galvanizing (Z275 = 275 g/m² zinc) offering 50+ years of indoor corrosion resistance. Heavy structural steel is shot-blasted to Sa 2.5 and coated with 2-coat epoxy/polyurethane paint or hot-dip galvanized per ISO 1461.

Yes. LGS is exceptionally safe in earthquakes because seismic inertial force is directly proportional to building mass. An LGS house is ~70% lighter than masonry and concrete, resulting in dramatically reduced seismic lateral forces.

Yes. LGS floor joists easily support corrugated metal decking with 50mm–80mm lightweight concrete screeds (or fiber-cement dry screed boards), providing a solid, quiet floor with excellent acoustic dampening.

Projektangebot für Stahlbau anfordern

Senden Sie uns Maße, Skizzen oder Ausschreibungsunterlagen für eine statische Vorprüfung und ein detailliertes Angebot.

1
2
3
4
5

Schritt 1: Welchen Gebäudetyp planen Sie?

Schritt 2: Projektstandort & Wunschmaße

Schritt 3: Bevorzugtes Lieferpaket & Hallenausstattung

Schritt 4: Projektzeitplan, Incoterms & Status

Schritt 5: Kontaktdaten & CAD / Pläne hochladen

Dateien hier ablegen oder zum Auswählen klicken
Unterstützt PDF, DWG, DXF, IFC, RVT, STEP, ZIP, RAR, JPG, PNG
Sofortige WhatsApp-Beratung